Research Status · v2.0.0 · Experimental Reference Implementation
Dashboard
Research status and scientific maturity
An experimental reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the identity architecture for the Aether family. 8 Python modules, 35 tests (93% coverage), and 2 experiments (S1, S6) executed. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument; F5 remains untested.
35
Tests Passed
93%
Coverage
8
Python Modules
2
Experiments Run
Status vocabulary:
Built implementation exists
Passed tests succeeded
Not falsified weaker than confirmed
Untested no evaluation
Deferred pending
Hypothesis specification only
v2.0.0 at a Glance
| Dimension | Status |
|---|---|
| Manuscript (v1.0.0) | Complete (33 pages) |
| Definitions / Propositions / Layers | 4 / 2 (proof sketches) / 5 |
| Implementation | Built src/aetheridentity/, 8 modules |
| Tests | 35 passed |
| Experiments | 2/6 executed (S1, S6); S2–S5 deferred |
| PyPI package | Published aetheridentity 2.0.0 |
| Real-world deployment | Not evaluated |
| Causal claims | None (argument only) |
The Eight Functional Dimensions
| # | Dimension | Focus | DOI |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AetherGit | Storage and versioning | 10.5281/zenodo.23976986 |
| 2 | AetherFlow | Integration and operational verification | 10.5281/zenodo.23979129 |
| 3 | AetherProof | Specification and structured evidence | 10.5281/zenodo.24013124 |
| 4 | AetherMesh | Distribution and eventual consistency | 10.5281/zenodo.24038038 |
| 5 | AetherGovern | Authority and policy | 10.5281/zenodo.24054524 |
| 6 | AetherRuntime | Monitoring and runtime assurance | 10.5281/zenodo.24078477 |
| 7 | AetherOrchestrate | Orchestration | 10.5281/zenodo.24095399 |
| 8 | AetherIdentity (candidate) | Identity and continuity | 10.5281/zenodo.24102739 |
Foundational Documents
| Document | Version | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Research Paper (PDF) | 1.0.0 | Published (Zenodo) |
| Figshare Preprint | 1.0.0 | Published (Figshare) |
| OSF Preregistration | 1.0.0 | Published (OSF) |
| Reference Implementation | 2.0.0 | Built (8 modules) |
| Test Suite | 2.0.0 | 35 passed |
| Experiments | 2.0.0 | 2/6 executed (S1, S6) |
| PyPI Package | 2.0.0 | Published |
Scientific Maturity
| Indicator | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Research problem | Specified | Identity gap in the Aether family |
| Central question | Specified | Four clauses mapping to F1–F5 |
| Formal definitions | Defined | 4 definitions |
| Propositions | Stated | 2 (proof sketches, not machine-checked) |
| Failure conditions | Stated | 5 (F1–F5) |
| Requirements | Stated | 6 (R1–R6) |
| Implementation | Built | 8 modules under src/aetheridentity/ |
| Tests | 35 passed | 93% coverage |
| Experiments | 2/6 | S1 (P2), S6 (F3) executed; S2–S5 deferred |
| PyPI package | Published | aetheridentity 2.0.0 |
| Real-world deployment | Not evaluated | No deployment |
| Causal claims | None | Argument only |
| Peer review | Not peer reviewed | Preprint status |
Publication Status
| Venue | Identifier / URL | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Zenodo | 10.5281/zenodo.24102739 | Published |
| Figshare | 10.6084/m9.figshare.34981891 | Published |
| OSF Preregistration | 10.17605/OSF.IO/B6AEN | Published |
| OSF Project | osf.io/5y783 | Published |
| PyPI | pypi.org/project/aetheridentity | Published |
| GitHub | github.com/gitdeeper15/aetheridentity | Active |
| GitLab | gitlab.com/gitdeeper15/aetheridentity | Active |
| Codeberg | codeberg.org/gitdeeper15/aetheridentity | Active |
| Bitbucket | bitbucket.org/gitdeeper15/aetheridentity | Active |
| Netlify | aetheridentity.netlify.app | Active |
Structural Counts
| Category | Count |
|---|---|
| Formal Definitions | 4 |
| Propositions | 2 (P1–P2, proof sketches) |
| Failure Conditions | 5 (F1–F5) |
| Requirements | 6 (R1–R6) |
| Identity Layers | 5 |
| Functional Dimensions | 8 (7 existing + 1 candidate) |
| Figures | 9 (6 exported) |
| References | 29 |
| Open Questions | 20 (Q1–Q20) |
| Evaluation Metrics | 9 (M1–M9) |
| Baselines | 5 (B1–B5) |
| Scenarios | 6 (S1–S6) |
| Threats to Validity | 7 |
| Python Modules | 8 |
| Tests | 35 |
| Experiments | 2 executed (of 6) |
Failure Conditions F1–F5
| ID | Claim under test | Status |
|---|---|---|
| F1 | Non-redundancy | Not falsified (identity lifecycle missing) |
| F2 | Orthogonality to verification | Not falsified (narrowly) |
| F3 | Boundary with governance | Inconclusive (fragile; tested in S6) |
| F4 | Decentralizability | Not falsified (with residuals) |
| F5 | Observable benefit | Untested |
"Not falsified" is a weaker status than "confirmed". F5 (observable benefit) remains untested. No condition is confirmed.
Requirements R1–R6
| ID | Requirement |
|---|---|
| R1 | Identity proof: an agent can prove it is who it claims to be |
| R2 | Continuity: identity persists across restarts and transfer between nodes |
| R3 | Reputation: behavioral history is bound to identity |
| R4 | Sybil resistance: multiple fabricated identities can be detected at a stated error rate, or their combined weight bounded |
| R5 | Delegation: authority can be transferred between identities with bounded scope |
| R6 | Partition tolerance: identity functions remain possible when nodes are disconnected |
The Five Identity Layers
| Layer | Question | Status |
|---|---|---|
| L1 — Identity | Who is the agent, and can it prove it? | Implemented |
| L2 — Continuity | Does the identity persist? | Implemented |
| L3 — Reputation | What is the behavioral history? | Implemented |
| L4 — Sybil Resistance | Is one entity behind many identities? | Implemented |
| L5 — Delegation | Can authority move with bounded scope? | Implemented |
Propositions P1–P2
| # | Proposition | Status |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | Determinism of Local Identity Issuance (restated) | Proof sketch (not machine-checked) |
| P2 | Irreducible Trust Anchor | Proof sketch (regress argument, not machine-checked) |
Both propositions are stated with proof sketches; neither is machine-checked. P1 bears on F4 (determinism of admission). P2 bears on F4 (irreducible anchor).
Evaluation Design (M1–M9, B1–B5, S1–S6)
| # | Metric | Direction / Constraint |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | Identity issuance accuracy | Higher is better |
| M2 | Continuity preservation | Higher is better |
| M3 | Reputation accuracy | Higher is better |
| M4 | Sybil detection rate (with false-positive rate) | Higher is better |
| M5 | Delegation scope correctness | Higher is better |
| M6 | Identity verification latency | Lower is better |
| M7 | Identity storage overhead | Lower is better |
| M8 | Revocation propagation latency | Lower is better |
| M9 | Convergence preservation | Constraint: must be zero if P1 holds |
Not fully executed. In v2.0.0, only S1 and S6 are executed. S2–S5 and most metrics are deferred.
v2.0.0 Experimental Results
| # | Experiment | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | S1 — Bootstrap (P2) | P2 not falsified (bootstrap requires an anchor) |
| 2 | S6 — Governance overlap (F3) | F3 inconclusive (fragile: holds in some uses, fails in others) |
Partial evaluation. S2–S5 are deferred, not passing. F1, F2, F4, and F5 are not evaluated in v2.0.0.
Open Questions Q1–Q20
| ID | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Q1–Q20 | Open | Spans identity proof, continuity, reputation, Sybil resistance, delegation, interfaces, methodology |
All 20 open questions remain unresolved in v2.0.0. Their full statements are in Section 10 of the paper.
Threats to Validity
| Type | Threat | Status |
|---|---|---|
| T1 | Construct validity | Report several metrics; invite independent review |
| T2 | Internal validity | Equal tuning budgets; ablations; shared seeds |
| T3 | External validity | No real-world deployment; no transfer claimed |
| T4 | Baseline strength | Well-documented baselines; external configuration review |
| T5 | Scenario selection | Pre-register; independent scenario proposals |
| T6 | Author bias | Independent review and replication |
| T7 | Model assumptions | Sensitivity runs; state assumptions with every result |
Research Status Statement
| Item | Status |
|---|---|
| Document type | Research article + reference implementation |
| Version / record | 2.0.0, November 2026 · AETHERIDENTITY-01 |
| DOI | 10.5281/zenodo.24102739 |
| Implementation | Built (8 modules) |
| Tests | 35 passed (93% coverage) |
| Experiments | 2/6 executed (S1, S6) |
| PyPI package | Published |
| Real-world deployment | None |
| Propositions P1–P2 | Proof sketches; not machine-checked |
| Byzantine evaluation | Not performed |
| Third-party claims | As reported; not independently verified |
| Review status | Not peer reviewed |
Status note (v2.0.0): This is an experimental reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the identity architecture for the Aether family. 8 Python modules, 35 tests (93% coverage), and 2 experiments (S1, S6) are executed. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument; F3 is inconclusive. F5 remains untested. S2–S5 are deferred. AetherIdentity is a candidate, not a result.