Research Status · v2.0.0 · Experimental Reference Implementation

Dashboard

Research status and scientific maturity

An experimental reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the identity architecture for the Aether family. 8 Python modules, 35 tests (93% coverage), and 2 experiments (S1, S6) executed. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument; F5 remains untested.

35
Tests Passed
93%
Coverage
8
Python Modules
2
Experiments Run
Status vocabulary: Built implementation exists Passed tests succeeded Not falsified weaker than confirmed Untested no evaluation Deferred pending Hypothesis specification only

v2.0.0 at a Glance

Snapshot of v2.0.0 maturity
DimensionStatus
Manuscript (v1.0.0)Complete (33 pages)
Definitions / Propositions / Layers4 / 2 (proof sketches) / 5
ImplementationBuilt src/aetheridentity/, 8 modules
Tests35 passed
Experiments2/6 executed (S1, S6); S2–S5 deferred
PyPI packagePublished aetheridentity 2.0.0
Real-world deploymentNot evaluated
Causal claimsNone (argument only)

The Eight Functional Dimensions

The Aether family dimensions and the identity candidate
#DimensionFocusDOI
1AetherGitStorage and versioning10.5281/zenodo.23976986
2AetherFlowIntegration and operational verification10.5281/zenodo.23979129
3AetherProofSpecification and structured evidence10.5281/zenodo.24013124
4AetherMeshDistribution and eventual consistency10.5281/zenodo.24038038
5AetherGovernAuthority and policy10.5281/zenodo.24054524
6AetherRuntimeMonitoring and runtime assurance10.5281/zenodo.24078477
7AetherOrchestrateOrchestration10.5281/zenodo.24095399
8AetherIdentity (candidate)Identity and continuity10.5281/zenodo.24102739

Foundational Documents

Status of foundational documents and artifacts
DocumentVersionStatus
Research Paper (PDF)1.0.0Published (Zenodo)
Figshare Preprint1.0.0Published (Figshare)
OSF Preregistration1.0.0Published (OSF)
Reference Implementation2.0.0Built (8 modules)
Test Suite2.0.035 passed
Experiments2.0.02/6 executed (S1, S6)
PyPI Package2.0.0Published

Scientific Maturity

Maturity indicators across the research lifecycle
IndicatorStatusNotes
Research problemSpecifiedIdentity gap in the Aether family
Central questionSpecifiedFour clauses mapping to F1–F5
Formal definitionsDefined4 definitions
PropositionsStated2 (proof sketches, not machine-checked)
Failure conditionsStated5 (F1–F5)
RequirementsStated6 (R1–R6)
ImplementationBuilt8 modules under src/aetheridentity/
Tests35 passed93% coverage
Experiments2/6S1 (P2), S6 (F3) executed; S2–S5 deferred
PyPI packagePublishedaetheridentity 2.0.0
Real-world deploymentNot evaluatedNo deployment
Causal claimsNoneArgument only
Peer reviewNot peer reviewedPreprint status

Publication Status

Archives and repositories
VenueIdentifier / URLStatus
Zenodo10.5281/zenodo.24102739Published
Figshare10.6084/m9.figshare.34981891Published
OSF Preregistration10.17605/OSF.IO/B6AENPublished
OSF Projectosf.io/5y783Published
PyPIpypi.org/project/aetheridentityPublished
GitHubgithub.com/gitdeeper15/aetheridentityActive
GitLabgitlab.com/gitdeeper15/aetheridentityActive
Codebergcodeberg.org/gitdeeper15/aetheridentityActive
Bitbucketbitbucket.org/gitdeeper15/aetheridentityActive
Netlifyaetheridentity.netlify.appActive

Structural Counts

Counts of formal and structural artifacts (v2.0.0)
CategoryCount
Formal Definitions4
Propositions2 (P1–P2, proof sketches)
Failure Conditions5 (F1–F5)
Requirements6 (R1–R6)
Identity Layers5
Functional Dimensions8 (7 existing + 1 candidate)
Figures9 (6 exported)
References29
Open Questions20 (Q1–Q20)
Evaluation Metrics9 (M1–M9)
Baselines5 (B1–B5)
Scenarios6 (S1–S6)
Threats to Validity7
Python Modules8
Tests35
Experiments2 executed (of 6)

Failure Conditions F1–F5

Falsification status of the five failure conditions
IDClaim under testStatus
F1Non-redundancyNot falsified (identity lifecycle missing)
F2Orthogonality to verificationNot falsified (narrowly)
F3Boundary with governanceInconclusive (fragile; tested in S6)
F4DecentralizabilityNot falsified (with residuals)
F5Observable benefitUntested
"Not falsified" is a weaker status than "confirmed". F5 (observable benefit) remains untested. No condition is confirmed.

Requirements R1–R6

The six identity requirements
IDRequirement
R1Identity proof: an agent can prove it is who it claims to be
R2Continuity: identity persists across restarts and transfer between nodes
R3Reputation: behavioral history is bound to identity
R4Sybil resistance: multiple fabricated identities can be detected at a stated error rate, or their combined weight bounded
R5Delegation: authority can be transferred between identities with bounded scope
R6Partition tolerance: identity functions remain possible when nodes are disconnected

The Five Identity Layers

Layers of the identity architecture
LayerQuestionStatus
L1 — IdentityWho is the agent, and can it prove it?Implemented
L2 — ContinuityDoes the identity persist?Implemented
L3 — ReputationWhat is the behavioral history?Implemented
L4 — Sybil ResistanceIs one entity behind many identities?Implemented
L5 — DelegationCan authority move with bounded scope?Implemented

Propositions P1–P2

Propositions and their proof status
#PropositionStatus
P1Determinism of Local Identity Issuance (restated)Proof sketch (not machine-checked)
P2Irreducible Trust AnchorProof sketch (regress argument, not machine-checked)
Both propositions are stated with proof sketches; neither is machine-checked. P1 bears on F4 (determinism of admission). P2 bears on F4 (irreducible anchor).

Evaluation Design (M1–M9, B1–B5, S1–S6)

Proposed metrics and their direction or constraint
#MetricDirection / Constraint
M1Identity issuance accuracyHigher is better
M2Continuity preservationHigher is better
M3Reputation accuracyHigher is better
M4Sybil detection rate (with false-positive rate)Higher is better
M5Delegation scope correctnessHigher is better
M6Identity verification latencyLower is better
M7Identity storage overheadLower is better
M8Revocation propagation latencyLower is better
M9Convergence preservationConstraint: must be zero if P1 holds
Not fully executed. In v2.0.0, only S1 and S6 are executed. S2–S5 and most metrics are deferred.

v2.0.0 Experimental Results

Results from experiments/S*/results.json
#ExperimentResult
1S1 — Bootstrap (P2)P2 not falsified (bootstrap requires an anchor)
2S6 — Governance overlap (F3)F3 inconclusive (fragile: holds in some uses, fails in others)
Partial evaluation. S2–S5 are deferred, not passing. F1, F2, F4, and F5 are not evaluated in v2.0.0.

Open Questions Q1–Q20

Open questions carried forward into future versions
IDStatusNote
Q1–Q20OpenSpans identity proof, continuity, reputation, Sybil resistance, delegation, interfaces, methodology
All 20 open questions remain unresolved in v2.0.0. Their full statements are in Section 10 of the paper.

Threats to Validity

Selected threats to validity
TypeThreatStatus
T1Construct validityReport several metrics; invite independent review
T2Internal validityEqual tuning budgets; ablations; shared seeds
T3External validityNo real-world deployment; no transfer claimed
T4Baseline strengthWell-documented baselines; external configuration review
T5Scenario selectionPre-register; independent scenario proposals
T6Author biasIndependent review and replication
T7Model assumptionsSensitivity runs; state assumptions with every result

Research Status Statement

Consolidated status of v2.0.0
ItemStatus
Document typeResearch article + reference implementation
Version / record2.0.0, November 2026 · AETHERIDENTITY-01
DOI10.5281/zenodo.24102739
ImplementationBuilt (8 modules)
Tests35 passed (93% coverage)
Experiments2/6 executed (S1, S6)
PyPI packagePublished
Real-world deploymentNone
Propositions P1–P2Proof sketches; not machine-checked
Byzantine evaluationNot performed
Third-party claimsAs reported; not independently verified
Review statusNot peer reviewed
Status note (v2.0.0): This is an experimental reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the identity architecture for the Aether family. 8 Python modules, 35 tests (93% coverage), and 2 experiments (S1, S6) are executed. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by argument; F3 is inconclusive. F5 remains untested. S2–S5 are deferred. AetherIdentity is a candidate, not a result.